>>> Read newsletter on LinkedIn <<<
One of the biggest decisions growing commerce brands face is this: Should we manage fulfillment in-house or partner with a third-party logistics (3PL) provider?
On the surface, handling fulfillment internally might seem like the cheaper option. But when you dig into the full scope of costs, labor, space, tech, shipping rates, and scalability — the picture gets more complex.
🏗️ In-house fulfillment: Control comes at a cost
Pros:
- Full control over processes, branding, and customer experience
- Flexibility to change operations on the fly
- Useful for small-scale or highly specialized operations
Hidden costs to consider:
- Warehousing space (rent, utilities, insurance)
- Hiring and managing warehouse staff
- Technology investment for inventory and order tracking
- Shipping rate negotiations (usually less favorable than 3PLs)
- Seasonal scaling challenges (hiring surges, equipment, storage)
Unless you have consistent, high-volume demand and the operational expertise to run logistics efficiently, in-house fulfillment can quickly become a drain on both capital and time.
📦 3PL fulfillment: Scale, speed, and savings
Pros:
- Variable cost model: Pay for what you use
- Lower shipping rates through carrier relationships
- Access to advanced tech (real-time inventory, automation, analytics)
- Quick scalability for growth or seasonality
- Frees up your team to focus on marketing, sales, and product
Things to watch:
- Some 3PLs offer businesses less direct control over the customer experience
- Integration and onboarding may take initial effort
- Quality and service levels vary — choose your 3PL partner wisely
💰 Which makes financial sense?
If your monthly order volume is low and predictable, in-house may be more cost-effective for now. But as soon as order complexity, volume, or growth ambitions kick in, the benefits of working with a 3PL almost always outweigh the overhead and hidden costs of staying in-house.
In most cases, outsourcing fulfillment to a 3PL becomes a strategic decision — not just a financial one. It’s about unlocking efficiency, improving customer experience, and enabling growth without being buried in logistics.
✅ The benefit
When you’re deciding between in-house fulfillment and a 3PL, don’t just compare costs — compare opportunity costs. What could your team do with the time, capital, and focus saved by handing off fulfillment to a logistics partner?
If you’re exploring 3PL solutions or want a cost comparison tailored to your business, Simple Global would be happy to connect. Let’s talk logistics that work for your growth.
